• @Mickey7@lemmy.worldOP
      link
      fedilink
      407 months ago

      Agreed he can be pompous but I think since he’s an astronomer he is making the point that if you were in space and looked at earth you would wonder why are there borders

        • Skua
          link
          fedilink
          117 months ago

          There are heaps of examples of those that aren’t political borders, though. I live between a river and some mountains. The other side of the river is another county but still the same country, and the other side of the nearest mountains isn’t even another county. Egypt is on both sides of the Nile and also on both sides of the Africa-Asia border, Russia is on both sides of the Urals and the Europe-Asia border (wherever you draw it, if you draw it at all), America is on both sides of the Rockies and so on

            • Skua
              link
              fedilink
              27 months ago

              No, I’m in Scotland. Isn’t the other side of the river from El Paso across the Mexican border anyway?

              • @WeirdGoesPro@lemmy.dbzer0.com
                link
                fedilink
                17 months ago

                Part of the other side of the river is Mexico, another part is New Mexico, the nearest mountains have Texas on both sides—it just happened to also fit your description. Kind of wild that there is a part of Scotland that has the same unusual artificial and natural barriers.

      • ddh
        link
        fedilink
        English
        147 months ago

        “If everyone was as wise as me, I wouldn’t suffer this tiresome charade”

        • ElPussyKangaroo
          link
          fedilink
          107 months ago

          Well, he’s ridiculing the fact that everything we have setup for governance is, in fact, made up. I don’t see why that’s pompous. I know his tweets tend to be a bit too pedantic for certain topics, but that is his persona. He is one of the few peopeople responsible for this generation finding science cool. He’s allowed that much.

        • @TheTetrapod@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          57 months ago

          If you close your eyes and imagine a future Star Trek utopia, are you still imagining borders? It’s a pretty standard opinion that borders are an outcropping of our worse natures and should eventually be left behind.

          • @Darrell_Winfield@lemmy.world
            link
            fedilink
            87 months ago

            Borders are absolutely in the star Trek utopia. Everything has borders. What we do about those borders is the difference.

            Each quadrant, solar system, etc has borders. These are even more arbitrary as the current state, county, and country borders across our world tend to follow natural terrain or longitude and latitude. None of these exist in space. But the quadrant borders are as easy to cross as for me to drive to my next US state. However, the Kardassian border is not so easy to cross, just like it’s not so easy for me to cross into North Korea.

            Borders are not the inherent issue here. Conflict is the inherent issue, and borders are how we try to minimize that conflict.

            • @wolfpack86@lemmy.world
              link
              fedilink
              27 months ago

              They should really issue some sort of identification showing to which quadrant you belong so that friendly quadrants will accept you as a visitor with open arms.